Inspired by a Letter to the Editor

Last week the Miami County Republic ran a guest column I wrote called "Fairness needs to be the focal point during this election season".  See, http://www.republic-online.com/opinion/article_0a843102-89bb-504f-9d70-04dfd607519b.html.  In this piece I skewered Paul Ryan as being an adherent of Ayn Rand's godless philosophy, the Romney/Ryan tax plan, the Browback tax plan, and certain (anti-abortion) single issue voters.

 

Today's Republic contains my first letter to the editor, not from me but about me.  I am delighted.  Public Opinion needs to be a two way street and I am grateful for the lady who sat down and put pen to paper to tell us how I made her feel. 

 

This lady's opening volley is that "we still live in the greatest nation, for now anyway".   That puzzled me, I could have seen something about politics making strange bedfellows or challenging my fuzzy math on tax policy.  Since I didn't take a stand on American greatness I went ahead and took a look at it.

 

Fortunately, the good people at the Pew Institute did all the work, http://pewresearch.org/pubs/2045/america-global-standing-most-say-among-greatest-but-not-single-greatest-nation.  It seems that Americans don't all agree that we are number one.  The differences spread out over a range of demographic categories.

 

First is how we view that question of greatness when you sort us by our ages.  Younger Americans are less likely to say that America is the greatest nation. 

Next Pew looked at how we answer that question based on our politics.  The most conservative are most likely to agree that America is the greatest nation on earth.  At the other end of the spectrum the most liberal are most likely to disagree with the statement.  Across the board 38% of all Americans say America is the greatest, 53% say we are among the world's great nations, and 8% say there are other nations greater than America.

The lady who wrote the letter then said something about which she and I will have to agree to disagree.  She thinks most voters are single issue voters looking out for themselves first. 

We may be talking about apples and oranges.  Single issue voters will only vote for candidates who agree with them on that issue.  For these voters their issue is a litmus test. 

Categorically, we know that all voters are not single issue voters.  For insight I visited an article published by the famous Pollsters at Gallup.  In an article written about single issue voters in the race between Kerry and Bush, I found the example I was looking for.  The article was written by Lydia Saad, a senior Gallup Poll Editor.  You can find the entire article online at http://www.gallup.com/poll/13786/abortion-issue-guides-one-five-voters.aspx.

 

My position is that the anti-abortion voters whose sole criteria in voting is to select anti-abortion candidates abdicate their power over all other issues.  What they get are legislators who wreck the environment, who defund our schools, who manipulate the tax code for the very rich, and do many other things that the voters would not approve if they sat down and thought about the votes of their legislators.  Instead these voters have become accustomed to being told what they want to hear.  They do not require accountability from their elected officials.

 

In Kansas the Romney/Ryan tax plan is not just hypothetical it is called the Brownback tax fiasco.  In Kansas those earning $25,000 or less will see a 5000% tax hike next year.  Back to the point, Kansans earning $25,000 or less, cannot afford to vote for their anti-abortion candidate, since those are the legislators who voted to increase their taxes.

 

For the record, I never said anything about gay marriage, nor do I feel obliged to respond to her rant on the topic.  You may note the "equality on board" logo on this Blog's page and know that I stand in solidarity with those who for too long have been denied equal protection of the law.  One does not need to be aggrieved by the injustice to be offended by it.

 

The letter's final valid point is well taken.  The lady suggested that voters pray before going to the polls.  That's good, but here she and I will have to again agree to disagree.  You see it is equally important to think before you vote.  Single issue voters don't do this.  Single issue voters get the government they deserve because they have squandered the power of the ballot box.